Prepare to embark on a sweet journey through Queens’ best cake spot, selected through a competitive reader’s choice award that highlight excellence in baking. Read on to find out who makes the Best Cake in Queens.
2025: Queens Voted Joe’s Sicilian Bakery Best Cake!
Joe’s Sicilian Bakery
212-16 48th Ave, Bayside
(718) 225-2272
A celebration isn’t complete without the perfect cake, and Joe’s Sicilian Bakery has mastered the art of crafting unforgettable confections. Honored as the 2025 Winner in the Cake category, this beloved bakery is renowned for its rich, moist cakes made with premium ingredients and a touch of Sicilian tradition. Whether you’re craving a classic tiramisu, a decadent chocolate masterpiece or a custom-designed cake for a special occasion, their expert bakers ensure every creation is as stunning as it is delicious. Each slice is a testament to their dedication to quality, flavor and artistry. From birthdays to weddings and everything in between, their cakes turn moments into memories. Experience the sweetness of excellence—treat yourself to an award-winning creation today!
2024: Queens Voted Joe’s Sicilian Bakery Best Cake!
Joe’s Sicilian Bakery
212-16 48th Ave, Bayside
(718) 225-2272
Everyone has an opinion on what makes a great cake (your grandmother, Martha Stewart, Paul Hollywood), but the people of Queens have voted Joe’s Sicilian Bakery the Best Cake in the Best of the Boro contest. Even the pickiest party princess would be hard pressed to find a disappointing option among the varied cakes available at this Bayside institution. (Opened in 1975, they’ve had plenty of cakes to practice perfecting their craft.) Even if you’re just not in the mood for cake, Joe’s is also a satisfying spot for cookies, breads, pizza and Italian pastries. (They’re just not as fun to stick candles in.)
2023: Queens Voted Joe’s Sicilian Bakery Best Cake!
Joe’s Sicilian Bakery
212-16 48th Ave, Bayside
(718) 225-2272
What do you look for in a cake? Is it the moisture that enhances the flavor? Maybe the right thickness in the sponge is what does it for you. How about a light and airy icing? Well, you’re in luck. Joe’s Sicilian Bakery is the place to go when you want the best cake in Queens. Since 1975, Joe’s Sicilian Bakery has provided Bayside residents with their tasty creations. Each cake is made with just the right amount of attention and care to ensure customers get the ultimate satisfaction. What’s truly showing of this bakery’s skills are the wide assortment of baked goods available to purchase. Anyone who can make quality bread, an assortment of some of the best cookies around, and pizza, deserves outstanding recognition.
2022: Queens Voted Just Delight-Full Best Cake!
Just Delight-Full
10218 159th Rd, Jamaica
(718) 845-3855 – justdelightfull.com
Custom cakes are creative confections when they come from JustDelight-full. The business makes it theirs to elevate your special celebration to a sweet sensation. Buttercream, whipped cream, cream cheese frosting are all like oils and a palette is to a painter, to these bakers. A child’s birthday puzzle cake will, well take the cake at your little one’s birthday party and a teenager’s coveted Gibson guitar can be replicated on a sheet cake in creamy colorful fondant. One-of-a-kind made-to-order cakes from JustDelight-full always end up in pictures. Poke around on Instagram and you’re going to find them somewhere. Amazing, beautiful, and delicious are fair hashtags to describe them.
2021: Queens Voted Just Delight-Full Bakery Best Cake!
Just Delight-Full
161-11 Cross Bay Blvd, Howard Beach
(718) 845-3855 – www.justdelightfull.com
At Just Delight-Full, dessert dreams come true. What’s your cake wish? A cake dipped in chocolate? A cake topped with Christmas sprinkles? A cake where cannoli filling comes out as soon as you cut into it? Each dessert is individually made with top-quality ingredients and is created with exquisite detail, and taste. Numerous hours are spent researching and designing individual displays for cakes, dessert tables, and party favors to cater to the desires of your event. The bakers at Just Delight-Full enjoy baking and it’s shows. Being the source of the best cake in the borough isn’t an easy feat. But it’s one this bakery accepts with the utmost pride!
2020: Queens Voted Martha’s Country Bakery Best Cake!
Martha’s Country Bakery
70-28 Austin St, Forest Hills
(718) 544-0088 – www.marthascountrybakery.com
If you want an amazing piece of cake, Martha’s Country Bakery is the place to go. They bake all of their cakes and other baked goods on site so the customer knows they’re getting the best bang for their buck with fresh products made with care. From whole cakes made for special occasions to simply wanting to satisfy your sweet tooth with a cake slice, Martha’s hopes to evoke a delightful, warm feeling from its customers each time.
2019: Queens Voted Martha’s Country Bakery Best Cake!
Martha’s Country Bakery
70-28 Austin Street, Forest Hills
718-544-0088 – www.marthascountrybakery.com
If you want an amazing piece of cake, Martha’s Country Bakery is the place to go. They bake all of their cakes and other baked goods on site, so the customer knows they’re getting the best bang for their buck with fresh products made with care.
2018: Queens Voted Martha’s Country Bakery Best Cake!
Martha’s Country Bakery
36-21 Ditmars Blvd, Astoria, NY 11105
(718) 545-9737 – www.marthascountrybakery.com
If you want an amazing piece of cake, Martha’s Country Bakery is the place to go. They bake all of their cakes and other baked goods on site, so the customer knows they’re getting the best bang for their buck with fresh products made with care.
2017: Queens Voted Martha’s Country Bakery Best Cake!
Martha’s Country Bakery
36-21 Ditmars Blvd, Astoria, NY 11105
(718) 545-9737
If you want an amazing piece of cake, Martha’s Country Bakery is the place to go. They bake all of their cakes and other baked goods on site, so the customer knows they’re getting the best bang for their buck with fresh products made with care.
